The amateur rugby in England in s. XIX: philosophy or social manipulation?

Authors

  • Stasinos Stavrianeas Universidad de Patrás (Grecia) Author

Keywords:

professionalism, Greece, sport, sociology, history.

Abstract

The August 27, 1995, Vernon Pugh, chairman of the committee of the International Rugby Board (IRB) for amateurism, said the Rugby happened to be a free sport. It thus ended more than a century of declared amateurism in this sport, and also ended a decade of discussions on shamateurism or concealed professionalism, in which the players were not paid to play but by work, whether real or fictitious, which gives the defending club. In that year, ended the anachronism of a late twentieth century sport governed by rules of Victorian England. How did he get to this situation? Dunning and Sheard argue that the phenomenon of amateurism in rugby in the nineteenth century was a complex instrument of social differentiation and must be analyzed from a historical standpoint and sociopolitical. In this line, Bádenas states that the British aristocracy in S. XIX used the growing interest in ancient Greek culture to assign values to the sport practiced at that time so that was conceptualized as a recreational activity characteristic of a social elite. To achieve this, extolled the values of a Greek amateur sports (which did not exist as such a concept) and enhanced those texts criticizing the professionalization of sports and its impact on sport. British theorists, as Mahaffy attributed to the ancient Greek sport values that matched the prototype athlete gentlemen of the Victorian era.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Bádenas, P. “El espíritu olímpico: mito moderno y realidad antigua” en In corpore sano, editado por F. García y B. Hernández. Madrid: UAM Ediciones, 2005

Baker, W.T. “William Webb Ellis and the origins of Rugby Football: The life and death of a Victorian myth”. Albion: A Quarterly Journal Concerned with British Studies. 13 (1981):117-130

Blackledge, P. “Rationalist capitalist concerns: William Cail and the Great Rugby Split of 1895”. The international journal of the history of sport, 18 (2001): 35-53

Bowen, J. “Education, ideology and the Ruling Class: Hellenism and english

public schools in the nineteenth century” en Rediscovering Hellenism editado por G.W. Clarke, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989

Chatziefstathiou, D. & Henry, I. “Hellenism and Olympism: Pierre de Coubertin and the Greek Challenge to the Early Olympic Movement”. Sport in History, 27 (2007): 24-43

Collins, T. “Amateurism and the rise of Managerialism: The case of Rugby Union, 1871-1995”. Sport in History, 30 (2010): 104-120

Curry, G., Dunning, E. & Sheard, K. “Sociological versus empiricist history: Some comments on Tony Collins’s ‘History, theory and the ‘‘civilizing process’’”. Sport in History, 26 (2006):110-123

Diem, R.D. Historia cultural del deporte. Barcelona: Bellaterra, 1984

Dunning, E.G. “Football in its early stages”. History Today, 13 (1963): 838-847

Dunning, E. & Sheard, K. Barabarians, gentlemen and players. Oxford: Martin Robertson, 1979

Gardner, P. New chapters in Greek history. London: John Murray, 1892

Gardiner, E.N. Greek athletic sports and festivals. London: McMillan, 1910

Gruneau, R. “‘Amateurism’ as a sociological problem: Some reflections inspired by Eric Dunning”. Sport in Society: Cultures, Commerce, Media, Politics, 9 (2006): 559-582

Hynes, S. The Edwardian turn of mind. NJ: Princeton University Press, 1968

Holt, R. Sport and the British. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1989

Holt, R. “The amateur body and the middle-class man: Work, Health and Style in Victorian Britain”. Sport in History, 26 (2006): 352-369

Jenkyns, R. The Victorians and Ancient Greece. Cambridge: MA, 1980

Jolly, W. Education: Its principles and practice as developed by George Combe. Londres: McMillan, 1879

Koulouri, C. “Athleticism and antiquity: symbols and revivals in nineteenth-century Greece”. The international journal of the history of sport, 15 (1998): 142-149

Kühn, C.G. Galeni Opera Omnia, Leipzig: Teubner, 1821-1833

Le Floc´hmoan, J. La génesis de los deportes. Barcelona: Labor, 1965

Leoussi, A.S. “Nationalism and racial Hellenism in nineteenth-century England and France”. Ethnic and racial studies, 20 (1997): 42-67

Mahaffy, J.P. The silver age of the greek world. Chicago: Chicago University Press, 1906

Mewaldt, J. Galeni in Hippocratis de natura hominis commentaria tria, Leipzig: Teubner, 1914

Renson, R. “Fair play: Its origins and meanings in sport and society”. Kinesiology, 41 (2009): 5-18

Riordan, J. “Amateurism, sport and the left: Amateurism for all versus amateur elitism”. Sport in History, 26 (2006): 468-483

Rivero, A. Deporte y modernización. Madrid: Dirección General de Deportes, 2003

Solá, J. “Historia del Rugby”. Apunts, 29, (1992): 6-11

Vamplew, W. Pay up and play the game: Professional sport in Britain, 1875–1914. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988

Wallace, J. Shelley and Greece: Rethinking romantic Hellenism. Nueva York: St. Martin`s Press, 1997

Williams, P. “Battle lines on three fronts: The RFU and the lost war against professionalism”. The international journal of the history of sport, 19, (2002): 114-136

Whitney, C.W. Sporting Pilgrimage. Nueva York: Harper & Brother, 1894

Young, D. “Mens sana in corpore sano? Body and mind in Ancient Greece”. The international journal of the history of sport, 22 (2005): 22-41

Downloads

Published

2013-10-30

Issue

Section

Artículos

How to Cite

The amateur rugby in England in s. XIX: philosophy or social manipulation?. (2013). Materiales Para La Historia Del Deporte, 11, 78-88. https://polired.upm.es/index.php/materiales_historia_deporte/article/view/4142